13oz jar of toasted coconut with dots of nut butters around it in a lined pattern

We've compiled a list of our most delectable, most giftable products, which will delight your loved ones (or yourself, we won't tell) no matter the occasion. We have something for everyone and every taste on upcoming holiday gift lists.

While we never make our nut butters with awards in mind, your loved ones might appreciate knowing that they're receiving award-winng products, notably a Good Food Award and two sofi Awards in 2023 alone! Plus, we were humbled to be ranked as No. 1 among high-end Peanut Butters by Tasting Table and No. 1 healthiest Almond Butter Brand by Eat This, Not That!

Almond butter and jam on toast on a white marble background

For the Nut Butter Fanatic:

Almond Butter or Peanut butter + Jam Subscriptions are for the lovers of that classic sandwich and the kids in all of us. Choose either almond or peanut butter and a 13-ounce jar will be paired with a small-batch jam and delivered every month to your door. Subscription offered include three, six or 12 months or ongoing. Cost varies; $22.95-$339.95.

Holiday Trio Gift Set includes three of our most popular nut butters: Chai Spice Peanut & Almond Butter, Maple Cinnamon Peanut and Pecan Butter and Carrot Cake Almond and Walnut Butter; $39.95.

Mini 3oz Winter Mix Variety Pack contains three-ounce jars of four nut butters that are perfect for fireside coziness: Chai Spice Peanut & Almond Butter, Chocolate Sea Salt Almond Butter, Maple Cinnamon Peanut & Pecan Butter, and Peanut Pecan Butter with Wildflower Honey; $25.95.

Chocolate Lover's Gift Set includes two chocolatey nut butters: Chocolate Sea Salt Almond Butter and a new limited batch Oat Milk Mocha Almond Butter. This pairing is a chocolate lover's dream. The gift set includes a 13-ounce jar of each nut butter for $31.95. (Available Nov 1)

For the Fur Babies:

Boredom Buster and Wag Butter Lick Pack is for your peanut butter loving pet. It includes one Boredom Busters Indulge Licking Mat and one 13-ounce jar of the Wag Butter of your choice: Coconut Chia, Banana Flax or Pumpkin Spice; $16.95.

Wag Butter Drip Kit - this gift set includes your choice of stylish doggie bandana with original artwork - or - our CycleDog Collar (made from 100% recycled plastic bottles), plus one 3oz jar, each, of our Wag Butter Recipes; $29.95-$34.95.

Paleo Nut Butter Collection

Multi-Packs to Fulfill Nut Butter Dreams:

- The Paleo Nut Butter 6-Pack is a collection of paleo-friendly nut butters that contain no cane sugar or peanuts (which are legumes). Each set includes the following: Almond Butter with Wildflower Honey, Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter, Cashew Butter with Coconut Nectar, Lemon Coconut Cashew Butter, Pistachio Crunch Almond Butter and Toasted Coconut Almond Butter; $80.95.

- Our Vegan Trio includes a 13-ounce jar of each of Pistachio Crunch Almond Butter, Lemon Coconut Cashew Butter and Vanilla Caramel Almond & Cashew Butter. All three nut butters are former limited batch releases that were so popular that they each earned a permanent spot in our lineup; $44.95.

Great Stocking Stuffers:

- This genius Nut Butter Mixer is the perfect gift for the natural nut butter lover on your list. Natural oil separation in nut butters is a good thing because it means your nut butter does not contain palm oil or hydrogenated vegetable oil. Designed to perfectly fit our 13-ounce jars, this mixer gets the job done with no mess; $11.50.

- Big Spoon Roasters Gift Card is the ideal gift for the lover of all things Big Spoon Roasters; available in denominations from $10-$100.

Shop all these gifts and more here!

Older Post Newer Post